• Hey there! Welcome to TFC! View fewer ads on the website just by signing up on TF Community.

Poor experience with the closure of my IDFC FIRST Classic credit card

CosmicCat

TF Ace
Hi fellow TFians!

On Saturday, 31st August 2024, I raised a service request for the closure of my IDFC FIRST Classic credit card as its limit was extremely low (Around ₹70,000) compared to my other cards and my annual income. I immediately received a confirmation that my card has been permanently blocked and in the app where it shows the card thumbnail, it was shown as "Requested for Closure."

On Tuesday, 3rd September, I received a call from someone from their Retention Team, who called me from her work mobile number instead of a landline (Was suspicious at first as it was being shown as spam on Truecaller). I explained her the reason of closure. She asked me to email them my ITR (As I'm self-employed) to banker@idfcfirstbank.com, and said that if they upgrade the limit to at least ₹1.5L, they can upgrade it to Select.

She also mentioned that she would reactivate my card, and the Service Request for the card closure would remain open for the next few days until the email team gives final response about limit enhancement. So I shared my ITR-V (The Acknowledgement Receipt of my ITR-3) to their email the same day.

However, the next day, on 4th September, in the morning, I received an SMS mentioning my card closure request has been cancelled because of "pending dues!" I was stunned, because I hadn't used this card for a while, and even the app was showing the Outstanding Balance as zero.

Also, after few hours, I received a reply to my card enhancement and upgrade request email, which said that they don't accept ITR-V. They asked me for the "Computation of Income" instead, and said that it should be below 4MB only! I thought they were referring to the ITR form itself, but it is over 50 MB in size. So how could I share it?

Then I asked their PNO helpline numbera about the incorrect closure of service request and false commitment. He first confirmed they closed it mistakenly as there were indeed no dues pending, and about enhancement, he said that the computation is provided by a CA.

I was dumbstuck. An ITR acknowledgement is accepted by everyone, and it is a valid authority, so why they rejected it?

Yesterday, 4th September, I also emailed their RNO team later in the evening about the incorrect cancellation of the service request, and provided them my final consent that I want to close this card, whose reply I am still awaiting.

So, in case the RNO raises a fresh service request for closure, what's my next course of action? As I originally raised the closure service request on 31st August (which is now cancelled as mentioned before), and the 8th working day is, 11th September, so if they close it after 11th September, should I ask for compensation of ₹500/day?
 
Last edited:
Yes, spent a whopping ₹1,500 in the last one year! 😂👌
So, it seems an ego issue. 🤣
No intention to offend! 🙂

You have already told that before you're only having closed FK Pay Later, no other card. IDFC has offered 60k that time is also good enough.

Now, it's 70k enjoy bro, it's LTF card.

Don't get indulged in such things, bekar ka jhamela aur time waste, jab spends bhi negligible hi hai then.
 
Last edited:
That explanation of closure gave them another chance to win back the customer!

If you're serious about closing a card, don't give them any reason or just say you don't like the card and ask them to proceed with the closure.

Emailing the RNO/PNO obviously does help and can be used if the response is unsatisfactory or there's no response.
 
They gave me a limit enhancement in the end of June 2024 of about ₹10,000 only, so I'm not sure if they will give another enhancement again now.
This is my theory. It can be an anecdote.
When my IDFC credit card spend was near to ~30% for 2 months they offered me limit enhancement automatically.
Anyway, they've asked me for the "Computation of Income" since I'm self-employed, and said ITR-V (Acknowledgement) wasn't enough.

Does anyone know what they mean by that?
 
Oh, this one? Thanks. I thought they were referring to the actual form instead, which is way beyond 4MB.
Well, ITR computation summaries all of your income, expenses, and investment etc. Hence it's easy to read and evaluate financial profile of any person.
I wish Income Tax portal provided that one button click solution for this as it's required for many things.

To save time you can simply upload the Excel file and your ITR to ChatGPT and ask it to fill info correctly. It'd do it within few seconds. You will have to spend time in proofreading only.
 
So, it seems an ego issue. 🤣
No, not really. I have a theory that this card impacted the credit limit of both my newly-approved cards, which were both approved without any income proof and no prior relationship.

This Classic card was the most recently approved card, and also with a limit way lesser than the limit of my other bank cards (My ICICI, HDFC, and IDFC cards were all approved around the same time last year). Both my IndusInd and Axis cards were approved last month, and came with a limit closer to this IDFC FIRST Classic card instead of my other two cards. Hence, for the future applications, na rahega baans, na bajegi bansuri.
 
Well, ITR computation summaries all of your income, expenses, and investment etc. Hence it's easy to read and evaluate financial profile of any person.
I wish Income Tax portal provided that one button click solution for this as it's required for many things.

To save time you can simply upload the Excel file and your ITR to ChatGPT and ask it to fill info correctly. It'd do it within few seconds. You will have to spend time in proofreading only.
Yes, but the thing with this computation is, it has no valid authority. Anyone can create it easily. However, an ITR acknowledgement is a valid proof and digitally signed, hence easy to validate its authenticity as well.
 
No, not really. I have a theory that this card impacted the credit limit of both my newly-approved cards, which were both approved without any income proof and no prior relationship.

This Classic card was the most recently approved card, and also with a limit way lesser than the limit of my other bank cards (My ICICI, HDFC, and IDFC cards were all approved around the same time last year). Both my IndusInd and Axis cards were approved last month, and came with a limit closer to this IDFC FIRST Classic card instead of my other two cards. Hence, for the future applications, na rahega baans, na bajegi bansuri.
meme-gif.webp
 
No, they haven't mentioned that.
What's is this then?
he said that the computation is provided by a CA
Here, it's mentioned that computation is provided by CA, means this job usually carried by CA so better to consult him, or he meant declaring/certification is required to consider it as a genuine one?

Better u know based on your concern.
 
Last edited:
What's is this then?

Here, it's mentioned that computation is provided by CA, means this job can only be done by CA, or he meant declaring/certification is required to consider it as a genuine one?

Better u know based on your concern.
In the email reply, they didn't mention that.

In the call, what he meant was, these computations and reports are usually made by a CA. He didn't necessarily ask me to provide a verified/stamped copy from a CA. For verification, ITR-V is enough as @EnthuCC has rightly said.
 
Don't get indulge in such things, bekar ka jhamela aur time waste, jab spends bhi negligible hi hai then.
Totally agree...I got into unnecessary hassle with IDFC to convert my First Select CC from Visa to MC. Raised complaint with RBIO too. Nothing happened. No point in taking anything up unless you are sure that you have a solid case (win or lose still depends on your luck). RBIO doesn't verify anything and blindly accept whatever bank tells them in most cases.
 
If that is the case why do you need a LE?

What is the highest limit you have on any CC?
They are really bad with LE...I too suffered with the same and that too in spite of showing them spends of 4L+ in a single statement on Axis card with 15L CL. They didn't give any LE (CL was 3L). And when I closed it, I got Wealth CC immediately with 10L CL.
 
If that is the case why do you need a LE?


What is the highest limit you have on any CC?
Can't reveal, but it's much-much more than my *I Don't Freaking Care* Classic credit card.


They are really bad with LE...I too suffered with the same and that too in spite of showing them spends of 4L+ in a single statement on Axis card with 15L CL. They didn't give any LE (CL was 3L). And when I closed it, I got Wealth CC immediately with 10L CL.
How did you get Wealth immediately after closing it?
 
What I feel is, it would have been better if RBI had the control of bank's system, can track and view all the logs of banks, this is when bank can't be able to twist the circumstances, can't even dare to lie, when RBI start to take strict against non voilation of rules, regulations, guidelines...and for concealment or for fraudulently presenting an essential fact.

What's your views on this bro? @sjmajumder
 
Back
Top