Should I close my Axis Vistara Platinum in place of Ace/Magnus/Select

[sidsonn]

[Noob Alert] Okay so before any flips off with my choice of the other 3 cards being from different spectrums, here are my reasons:

Why I want to close Vistara Platinum: I already have a SBI Vistara Prime card which gives me better points and a higher tier benefit in Vistara flights. But I still want an Axis card for their offers and can only place my finger on Ace, Magnus and Select (Already pre-approved for all three)

Ace: Don't think I need to give a reason for wanting Ace.
Magnus/Select: Though I won't be able to hit the 1L/M most of the time (maybe only once or twice during the year), but I mainly want it for the reward system and the edge points in GYFTR which I would then use to convert to mainly vouchers and airmiles

 

[jigar]

even if you hit 1lakh spend 2-3 times a year Magnus is worthy

 

[Avijeet]

1. Magnus + ACE (5%/4%/2%).. i would rate ACE over SELECT
2. SBI PRIME VISTARA

 

[sidsonn]

1. Magnus + ACE (5%/4%/2%).. i would rate ACE over SELECT
2. SBI PRIME VISTARA

@Avijeet So you would suggest that I should go for Magnus over Ace?

 

[Avijeet]

@Avijeet So you would suggest that I should go for Magnus over Ace?

Magnus any day till 1L+

But Ace has it's own benefits....

i would say Magnus+Ace Combo is far better than Magnus+Select Combo