• Hey there! Welcome to TFC! View fewer ads on the website just by signing up on TF Community.

AXIS Atlas vs HDFC Regalia Gold vs AXIS Horizon vs HSBC TravelOne

Status
The first post in this thread is a WikiPost, and can be edited by anyone with the appropriate permissions.

helloworld

TF Legend
This is a wiki post, so anyone with appropriate permissions can edit and make necessary changes.

General Note:​

Redemption calculations are assumptions for illustrative purposes and may vary. Please confirm specific terms directly with card issuers.

Terminology:​

  • EM: Edge Miles (Axis Rewards)
  • RP: Reward Points (HDFC Rewards)
  • FYF: First Year Free
  • JF: Joining Fee
  • LTF: Lifetime Free
  • AF: Annual Fee
  • BV: Brand Vouchers (e.g., Regalia Gold Milestone Benefit)
  • SFV: SmartBuy Flight Voucher (e.g., Regalia Gold Milestone Benefit)
  • 3Q/5Q: Quarters (for Regalia Gold milestones)
  • TE: Travel Edge (Axis Travel Booking Platform)
  • MP: Mile Point (Axis Redemption Value for EM)

Joining Fee and Benefits:

Category
Atlas
Horizon
Regalia Gold
TravelOne​
Joining Fee₹5900₹3540₹2950 (or FYF/LTF)₹5900
Welcome Benefit2.5K EM5K EM₹2500 Voucher (if fee paid)₹1000 Cashback + 3K RP (if spent 1L in 90 days)
Annual Fee₹5900₹3540₹2950 (or waived >₹4L spends)₹5900 (or waived >₹8L spends)
Renewal BenefitUp to 5K EM (Tier based)
0 (Silver Tier)
2.5K EM (Gold Tier)
5K EM (Platinum Tier)
1.5K EMNone (but waived for >₹4L)None (but waived for >₹8L)


Spend Rewards:

Category
Atlas
Horizon
Regalia Gold
TravelOne​
Travel (Airlines, Hotels and Travel EDGE)5 EM/₹1005 EM/₹1004 RP/₹150 (higher via SmartBuy)4 RP/₹100 (incl. travel aggregators)
Marks & Spencer, Myntra, Reliance Digital, Nykaa!2 EM/₹1002 EM/₹10020 RP/₹1502 RP/₹100
General2 EM/₹1002 EM/₹1004 RP/₹1502 RP/₹100


Milestone Benefits:

Cumulative Spends
Atlas
Horizon
Regalia Gold
TravelOne​
1.5L Spends/Year--₹1500 BV (1Q)-
3L Spends/Year2.5K EM---
5L Spends/Year--₹4500 BV (3Q) + ₹5000 SFV = ₹9500-
7.5L Spends/Year5K EM (Gold Tier)-₹ 7500 BV (5Q) + ₹ 5000 SFV = ₹12.5K-
12L Spends/Year---10K RP
15L Spends/Year10K EM (Platinum Tier)---


Redemption Options:

Domestic Options
Atlas
Horizon
Regalia Gold
TravelOne​
TravelEdge/SmartBuy1 EM = ₹11 EM = ₹11 RP = ₹0.50p-
Accor, Marriott,
Wyndham (Gr. A)
2 EM = 1 MP (Marriott)
1 EM = 2 MP (Others)
Group A: 30K EM Limit/Year
Group B: 1.2L EM Limit/Year
1 EM = 1 MP
Group A: 1L EM Limit/Year
Group B: 4L EM Limit/Year
1 RP = up to 0.5 MP
(Accor, Wyndham)
1 RP = ₹1
AirIndia, ITC, IHG (Gr. B)1 EM = 2 MP1 EM = 1 MP1 RP = upto 0.5 MP (IHG)1 RP = ₹1
Products/Vouchers1 EM = ₹0.20p1 EM = ₹0.20p1 RP = upto ₹ 0.35p
Gold Catelogue: 1 RP = 0.65p
-
Statement Credit--1 RP = ₹0.20p-


Lounge Access:​

Location
Atlas
Horizon
Regalia Gold
TravelOne​
Domestic8 (Silver), 12 (Gold), 18 (Platinum)32 visits (VISA), 24 visits (MC)12 visits6 visits
International4 (Silver), 6 (Gold), 12 (Platinum)8 visits6 visits4 visits


Exclusions:

  • Atlas: Jewlry, Rent, Govt., Insurance, Fuel, Utilities, Wallet
  • Horizon: Rent, Govt., Insurance, Fuel, Utilities, Wallet, Education, Transportation & Toll
  • Regalia Gold: Rent, Govt., Wallet
  • TravelOne: Jewlry, Rent, Govt., Insurance, Fuel, Utilities, Wallet, Education

Net Return:

Ranges in percentage (e.g., 9.4% to -0.27%) explain best-to-worst-case returns (possible return on your spending after factoring in joining fees, and milestone bonuses for specific spending levels).
  • Left Value (e.g., 9.4%)
    • This is the maximum reward rate achievable through optimal usage, like earning on Travel Edge purchases and redeeming at a high value (e.g., 1 mile = 2 INR). This rate takes effort but can be reached with strategic spending.
  • Right Value (e.g., -0.27%)
    • This is the minimum achievable rate through regular spending and basic redemption (e.g., 1 mile = 1 INR). This is straightforward and possible for all cardholders.
  • So, for any given spending amount, you can expect a reward rate between these two values. The lower end is your minimum return, while the upper end is achievable with careful planning.

= Spend Rewards + Milestone Benefits + Welcome Benefits - Fee / Spends

Cumulative Spends
Atlas (1 EM = ₹2 to ₹1)​
Horizon (1 EM = ₹1)​
Regalia Gold (1 RP = ₹0.50p)​
TravelOne (1 RP = ₹1)​
1.5L Spends/Year10K EM to 5.5K EM - 5.9K Fee (JF)
= 9.4% to -0.27%
12.5K to 8K EM - 3540 Fee (JF)
= 5.97
% to 2.97%
20K RP to 4K RP - 450 Fee (JF)
= 7.36% to 2.03%
6K RP to 4K RP - 1900 Fee (JF)
= 2.73% to 1.4%
3L Spends/Year20K EM to 11K EM - 5.9K Fee (JF)
= 11.36% to 1.7%
20K to 11K - 3540 Fee (JF)
= 5.48% to 2.48%
40K RP to 8K RP - 450 Fee (JF)
= 7.01% to 1.68%
12K RP to 6K RP - 1900 Fee (JF)
= 3.36% to 1.36%
5L Spends/Year30K EM to 15K EM - 5.9K Fee (JF)
= 10.82% to 1.82%
30K to 15K - 3540 Fee (JF)
= 5.29% to 2.29%
66.67K RP to 13.33K RP - 450 Fee (JF)
= 8.47% to 3.14%
20K RP to 10K RP - 1900 Fee (JF)
= 3.62% to 1.62%
7.5L Spends/Year45K EM to 22.5K EM - 5.9K Fee (JF)
= 11.21% to 2.21%
-1L RP to 20K RP - 450 Fee (JF)
= 8.27% to 2.94%
-
12L Spends/Year---58K RP to 34K RP - 1900 Fee (JF)
= 4.67% to 2.67%
15L Spends/Year87.5K EM to 42.5K EM - 5.9K Fee (JF)
= 11.27% to 2.44%
---

Cumulative SpendsAtlasHorizonRegalia Gold
TravelOne​
1.5L Spends in a year10K EM to 5.5K EM - 11.8K Fee (JF+AF)
= 5.4% to -4.2%
14K to 9.5K EM - 7080 Fee (JF+AF)
= 4.61
% to 1.61%
20K RP to 4K RP - 3.4K Fee (JF+AF)
= 7.23% to 0.06%
6K RP to 4K RP - 7800 Fee (JF+AF)
= -1.2% to -2.53%
3L Spends in a year20K EM to 11K EM - 11.8K Fee (JF+AF)
= 9% to -0.25%
21.5K to 12.5K - 7080 Fee (JF+AF)
= 4.8% to 1.8%
-12K RP to 6K RP - 7800 Fee (JF+AF)
= 1.93% to -0.6%
5L Spends in a year30K EM to 15K EM - 11.8K Fee (JF+AF)
= 9.64% to 0.64%
31.5K to 16.5K - 7080 Fee (JF+AF)
= 4.88% to 1.88%
66.67K RP to 13.33K RP - 3.4K Fee (JF+AF)
= 9.8% to 2.54%
20K RP to 10K RP - 7800 Fee (JF+AF)
= 2.56% to 0.44%
7.5L Spends in a year47.5K EM to 25K EM - 11.8K Fee (JF+AF)
= 10.92% to 1.73%
-1L RP to 20K RP - 3.4K Fee (JF+AF)
= 9.83% to 2.53%
-
12L Spends in a year---58K RP to 34K RP - 1900 Fee (JF+AF)
= 4.67% to 2.67%
15L Spends in a year92.5K EM to 47.5K EM - 11.8K Fee (JF+AF)
= 11.45% to 2.36%
---


Recommendations:​

  1. Horizon: Best for generic spends, especially below ₹3L annually.
  2. Atlas: Optimal for heavy spenders and best when redeeming through 1:2 MP for travel/hotel partnerships.
  3. Regalia Gold: Balanced choice for spending up to ₹7.5L with milestone benefits. Redemptions available for non-travel too.
  4. TravelOne: Horizon better compared to this card.

 
Last edited:
@drsel or anyone who has multi-year experience with Atlas, could you clarify below point:

View attachment 75030

So, if we take below example.. what would be this person Tier?

2024: Silver (new Atlas holder) and spent 5L in that year.
2025: Is it no Tier?

So, basically Atlas has only two tiers (after recent devaluation), which is either Gold or Platinum?
Before devaluation silver had a renewal benefit of 2500 EM, so they had 3 tiers and made sense. Now it doesn't make a lot of sense to keep silver tier but yeah that's how it is.
 
Because you cannot get downgraded from the lowest level or bottom

Before devaluation silver had a renewal benefit of 2500 EM, so they had 3 tiers and made sense. Now it doesn't make a lot of sense to keep silver tier but yeah that's how it is.

This is about lounge benefits after renewal. While re-checking recently, I came across this query and reached out to support, but the responses were mixed. I’ve also sent a mail for clarification and am posting here in case I missed anything.

I doubt ₹5900 alone covers lounge access anymore, especially with Axis, where even Magnus has spend requirements now. Just checking if anyone has more insights or confirmation on this.
 
This is about lounge benefits after renewal. While re-checking recently, I came across this query and reached out to support, but the responses were mixed. I’ve also sent a mail for clarification and am posting here in case I missed anything.

I doubt ₹5900 alone covers lounge access anymore, especially with Axis, where even Magnus has spend requirements now. Just checking if anyone has more insights or confirmation on this.
Only atlas, burgundy private and reserve doesn't have any spend threshold
 
Update: The latest notification from Axis Bank, effective from 20th December 2024, does not impact the previously provided calculations. The values above remain consistent with the updated terms.

Just mind that bulk redemption may reduce the redemption fee overall.
 
Status
The first post in this thread is a WikiPost, and can be edited by anyone with the appropriate permissions.
Back
Top