BROADLY: Compare how these numbers from following charts play.
SPECIFICALLY: ONLINE largely, not much offline. I do not yet or will have Huge spends.. until medical issues are fully fixed so...
Note:
AMEX MRCC acceptance offline not an issue.
Magnus fees not an issue (Paid & used 10k Voucher) + Mag Burgundy via True Burgundy in process.
Annual fee of SBI CB mostly LTF via Diwali spend.
Pondering MRCC vs Magnus "ONLINE" spend ROI over SBI CB 5%?
- What spends make sense moving off my SBI CB and/ or not? (More personal context in next reply).
- Is 4 x 1500 on MRCC worth my while? Whats its value?
(for $ or Flights instead of comparing via SkyScanner & paying ASAP)
(Outside of Taj/ Marriot or Fancy Hotels?)
I found these comparison tables / spreadsheets shared in the forums and I'd like to figure how to gauge whats REAL?
REFERENCE DATA:
https://www.technofino.in/community...pay-amazon-shopping-voucher.16673/post-339912
@CCUser_1999
@drsel
Can someone counter this math?
UPDATE: Maybe there are more such charts sheets people have made or use? Will add here for reference.
SPECIFICALLY: ONLINE largely, not much offline. I do not yet or will have Huge spends.. until medical issues are fully fixed so...
Note:
AMEX MRCC acceptance offline not an issue.
Magnus fees not an issue (Paid & used 10k Voucher) + Mag Burgundy via True Burgundy in process.
Annual fee of SBI CB mostly LTF via Diwali spend.
Pondering MRCC vs Magnus "ONLINE" spend ROI over SBI CB 5%?
- What spends make sense moving off my SBI CB and/ or not? (More personal context in next reply).
- Is 4 x 1500 on MRCC worth my while? Whats its value?
(for $ or Flights instead of comparing via SkyScanner & paying ASAP)
(Outside of Taj/ Marriot or Fancy Hotels?)
I found these comparison tables / spreadsheets shared in the forums and I'd like to figure how to gauge whats REAL?
REFERENCE DATA:
https://www.technofino.in/community...pay-amazon-shopping-voucher.16673/post-339912
@CCUser_1999
Let me be the kind member... 🙂
These are not all cards just the top cards as per me.
Magnus assumes 4:5 conversion with Burgundy account.
Vouchers bought through the respective reward multiplier portals.
Point value is taken which can bit conservative.
Though its pretty self explanatory but happy to answer in case of any doubt.
Card Spend Processing Fee Total Charge Base Points Bonus Points Milestone Points Total Points Conversion to Mile Point Value Net Reward Post Charges Eff Reward Rate Diners 20000 767 20767 665 1330 0 1995 1 1 1228 6.14% Magnus 10000 0 10000 600 600 0 1200 0.8 1 960 9.60% Amex Plat 10000 0 10000 250 1000 0 1250 1 0.5 625 6.25% Amex MRCC 20000 0 20000 400 400 2000 2800 1 0.5 1400 7.00% Amex MRCC 6000 0 6000 120 120 1000 1240 1 0.5 620 10.33% Amex Plat Travel 400000 0 400000 8000 8000 40000 56000 1 0.5 28000 7.00% Amex Gold 6000 0 6000 120 480 1000 1600 1 0.5 800 13.33% Infinia 20000 767 20767 665 2660 0 3325 1 1 2558 12.79%
@drsel
I beg to differ with the others
Atlas is far far better than any Amex card.
Atlas gives 10% return on direct Hotel bookings direct flight bookings and all Traveledge spends.
Atlas gives 4% return on all non travel bookings and offline spends.
In fact the only card giving a higher return of 4.8% on offline spends is Magnus Burgundy.
Amex cards cannot even be considered for offline spends because hardly any merchant will accept them, because the merchant has to pay 3% commission MDR.
Amex rewards are maximum 5.5% with MRCC (1500 x 4 per month, less 885 annual fees x 1.33 years) and slightly less 4.71% for platinum travel, after considering Rs.5900 renewal fee, 10000 hotel voucher worth Rs.6000, 48000 points at 39 paisa
Platinum travel rewards calculator ---
6000 + (48000 x 0.39)=Rs.24720
24720 on 4 lacs is 6.18% return
24720--5900 renewal fee=18820
18820 on 4 lacs spend is 4.71 %
Dang! So better to get 5% CB via SBI CB?Please deduct the Amex MRCC annual fees of 885 (50% discount) on a pro rata basis for 7.5 months out of 12 months.
Also let's assume for the sake of simplicity, that Amazon pay vouchers are worth 100% cash, because they are quasi cash.
7000-553/150000 works out to 4.30% return
But remember that Amazon pay vouchers can be bought at a discount of 5% or more
Can someone counter this math?
1% Lost over that time?Using the same logic and calculations, Amex MRCC 1500 x 4 gives you a higher return, after deducting 885 annual fees on a pro rata basis for 16 months and spending 96000 in 16 months
Approx 6.06% return ( assuming Amazon pay is worth 100% cash).
But there is a much longer waiting period of 16 months.
UPDATE: Maybe there are more such charts sheets people have made or use? Will add here for reference.
Last edited: