CarbonLogic
TF Buzz
Hello everyone, I am creating this thread to cover and clarify some basic points of opening savings accounts in a couple of banks that I have shortlisted
UPDATE: 05-04-2025
I applied for Kotak 811 Super Savings Account and HDFC SavingsMax Account on 1st April 2025. Just wanted to share my experience and timeline of events for both.
Kotak811 Super:
1st April:
2nd April:
3rd April:
4th April:
5th April:
HDFC SavingsMax: ( I want to personally thank @am11 for clarifying my doubts before and after account opening! )
1st April:
2nd April:
3rd April:
4th April:
So far the experience of Opening the accounts online for both banks have been decent. Definitely not completely smooth for me. They made me anxious quite a few times. I did not worry much about delivery of WelcomeKit since it was handled by BlueDart.
But I have to says Kotak811 looks and feels much more Premium than HDFC SavingsMax.
I intend on opening a basic savings account in HDFC(done), ICICI, Axis(on hold), Kotak(done) andmaybe AU
Why? In order to eventually get pre-approved offers for their CCs OR increase my chances of getting a CC application approved from them. For example:
In the CC department:
1. I applied for AmazonPay CC in Feb since it was showing me the offer on Amazon but it got instantly rejected with the reason no credit history. I was kind of expecting this but had my fingers crossed. Bad luck. At present its on a 130day cool down
2. Applied for Supercard last month: 10k FD, did a small txn, paid bill this month. It has generated Experian credit history @ 786 points. No CIBIL yet. Will continue to use this card for the foreseeable future. I am using it mainly on Myntra for the 5% CB for a max of 150 per month. Keeping the usage under 30% (2700 INR).
Coming to the banks (since thats what I would like to discuss in this post), heres what I have shortlisted so far. Please feel free to correct me or give your valuable points:
Note: I donot intend to do large FDs as of now, would like to go with the MAB route. Also at present I dont think I can qualify for the different banking programs so would like to stay out of that unless its feasible to get into one
1. HDFC (Opened SavingsMax)
Seems pretty straigthforward here, below are the 2 accounts I shortlisted. In another thread a member had mentioned that Millennia DC had become slightly better than ES Platinum DC but the latter is still a better account so I am still on the fence here.
2. ICICI (Tried opening online but on the next page it simply tells you to go to Branch)
This is the confusing one as website shows only 3in1, Family360, WM Savings and Private Banking Savings options
When I go here and click on Apply for Savings Account > Regular > it shows that I can open Savings Acc with no Initial Funding Requirement.
I havent proceeded yet because some members have mentioned that when they applied from here, on the next page it just tells them to go to Bank Branch.
-Some have also mentioned that there is an Initial funding of 95k, which converts the account to 0 MAB acc when infact originally the account was supposed to be a 10k MAB account. So would like some clarification on this.
If I do proceed with the 95k funding, can I withdraw the entire amount in a couple of days and will the account remain 0 MAB for LifeTime or would I have to maintain some balance in it? Also which DC do you get here and does it have a JF and AF? Not able to find proper documentations.
3. Axis
After going through this thread, I have decided to put Axis on hold. Since my aim for this account was Airtel Axis CC, I will try applying for the CC directly
Once again 2 straightforward accounts here
4. AU SFB
5. Kotak (Opened 811 SuperSavings)
I dont see much of a difference between the two, the ZeroBalance Digital SB should suffice with just VDC.
Also would it make sense to go for 811 Super Savings, assuming I dont get put on a waitlist? It does not have any MAB requirement either but subscription fee of 300/yr is applicable + every month you have to do a hard deposit of 5000 in a single txn. Can this be immediately withdrawn?
Thank you for reading till the end!
I will keep updating the post as I receive clarification and suggestions.
Your help is greatly appreciated!
- At present: I have a savings acc in SBI, have had it for ~15 years now.
- Employment: General Physician at a charitable Clinic that pays a monthly salary but its not exactly salary. Pseudosalary, no TDS or anything corporate, kind of off the books hence I dont think I can open a salary account.
- Annual: ~4L
- This will be increasing a bit later as I intend to do my masters soon
UPDATE: 05-04-2025
I applied for Kotak 811 Super Savings Account and HDFC SavingsMax Account on 1st April 2025. Just wanted to share my experience and timeline of events for both.
Kotak811 Super:
1st April:
- Applied online around 12pm with 5k Initial Funding
- Process was smooth up until KYC. Video KYC was not available, it was giving me the option to book a slot for physical KYC.
- However I logged into the 811 App with the MPIN and there it somehow showed me the option to complete kyc through vKYC. Tapped on it and I was connected to an agent within 1 minute. VKYC went smoothly. So if anyone planning to open the account online is not getting the option for vKYC, just log into your app and go from there. This is sort of a workaround I would say.
- Account was in restricted mode showing status as '811 Lite'.
- Virtual Debit Card was instantly issued as well.
- At around mindnight before 12am, 300 INR deducted from balance for Annual Fee for the Super Subscription/Program. Account updated to Full KYC status.
- Activmoney was automatically enabled but I disabled it since I dont intend to use it.
2nd April:
- Account was converted to Super 811 from 811 Lite, received SMS alert for the same.
- Received SMS that Kotak has received SuperDC request
- Received SMS that Kotak has received Chequebook request (both separate sms)
- App Icon changed! Not something I expected. It changed from regular 811 to 811 Super style (black to red gradient)
- App loading animation changed
3rd April:
- Received SMS that DC was issued.
4th April:
- Received SMS from BlueDart that WelcomeKit dispatched
5th April:
- WelcomeKit received at 1:30pm
- Chequebook has 25 leaves
- Debit Card has Gradient color from Black to Red. I was expecting this. Till this time I thought the Red color is for Regular 811 Savings account and Silver color is for the 811 Super account. But I have to say this was a pleasant surprise. The gradient color and all the typography on the card itself is very Beautiful.
- I have to say Kotak did a fantastic job with the Debit Card and Welcome Kit!
- Note: theres no Passbook, a separate request for Passbook can be made through the App. I have not done that yet. I asked a youtuber who made a video on requesting the passbook and he mentioned its actually free of cost for ordering the passbook 1st time. So will look into it and update.
HDFC SavingsMax: ( I want to personally thank @am11 for clarifying my doubts before and after account opening! )
1st April:
- Applied online around 3pm
- Process was smooth with instant VKYC.
- No initial funding but Deposited 25k as MAB is 25k for SavingsMax account
- Checked branch details, branch was somewhere in Mumbai even though I selected a branch near to me during application process, so I applied for Account Transfer through website (I live in Hyderabad)
- In evening received EMail that account transfer failed because there was already a request for account transfer.
- In evening DebitCard was issued and linked to my account. Details of type of card was not yet visible. It only showed image of EasyShop Platinum DC
2nd April:
- Account transfer completed to the Branch that I had selected during application. So it seems like new online accounts probably open in that one Mumbai branch but then get automatically transferred to selected branch.
- Received Email that Account is now active (emails are arriving a little late and not corresponding to real time activities on the account)
3rd April:
- Received SMS to validate my Email
- Received Welcome Email with PDF containing account details + Mention of Welcome kit
- Received whatsapp msg that Welcome Kit has been dispatched via BlueDart
4th April:
- WelcomeKit delivered at 9am
- Instead of easyshop platinum card received NEW Platinum Card and I have to be honest, this card looks quite horrible in design when compared to the Kotak 811 SuperDC. Even the Easyshop Platinum card looks better than this. So I think it is official that you no longer get Easyshop Platinum DC with the SavingsMax account instead you get the New Platinum Card
- Cheque book has only 5 leaves
So far the experience of Opening the accounts online for both banks have been decent. Definitely not completely smooth for me. They made me anxious quite a few times. I did not worry much about delivery of WelcomeKit since it was handled by BlueDart.
But I have to says Kotak811 looks and feels much more Premium than HDFC SavingsMax.
I intend on opening a basic savings account in HDFC(done), ICICI, Axis(on hold), Kotak(done) and
Why? In order to eventually get pre-approved offers for their CCs OR increase my chances of getting a CC application approved from them. For example:
- HDFC: Swiggy (Co-brand, its showing me LTF offer in app but dont want to risk applying it rn), Millennia (if and when it becomes LTF)
- ICICI: AmazonPay (Co-brand, applied and rejected since I did not have credit history now on 130d cooldown), Coral (if and when it shows LTF for instant discount offers)
- Axis: Airtel Axis (Co-brand)
- SBI: Cashback (King of CB), Simplyclick (will think about this, for instant discount offers)
- Kotak: Myntra (will wait for LTF offer if its possible)
- AU: Ixigo (currently LTF)
In the CC department:
1. I applied for AmazonPay CC in Feb since it was showing me the offer on Amazon but it got instantly rejected with the reason no credit history. I was kind of expecting this but had my fingers crossed. Bad luck. At present its on a 130day cool down
2. Applied for Supercard last month: 10k FD, did a small txn, paid bill this month. It has generated Experian credit history @ 786 points. No CIBIL yet. Will continue to use this card for the foreseeable future. I am using it mainly on Myntra for the 5% CB for a max of 150 per month. Keeping the usage under 30% (2700 INR).
Coming to the banks (since thats what I would like to discuss in this post), heres what I have shortlisted so far. Please feel free to correct me or give your valuable points:
Note: I donot intend to do large FDs as of now, would like to go with the MAB route. Also at present I dont think I can qualify for the different banking programs so would like to stay out of that unless its feasible to get into one
1. HDFC (Opened SavingsMax)
Seems pretty straigthforward here, below are the 2 accounts I shortlisted. In another thread a member had mentioned that Millennia DC had become slightly better than ES Platinum DC but the latter is still a better account so I am still on the fence here.
Regular Savings - 10k MAB, paid Millennia DC (590pa)- SavingsMax - 25k MAB, LTF
EasyshopNew Platinum DC ( As per advice by @Fini7777 )
2. ICICI (Tried opening online but on the next page it simply tells you to go to Branch)
This is the confusing one as website shows only 3in1, Family360, WM Savings and Private Banking Savings options
When I go here and click on Apply for Savings Account > Regular > it shows that I can open Savings Acc with no Initial Funding Requirement.
I havent proceeded yet because some members have mentioned that when they applied from here, on the next page it just tells them to go to Bank Branch.
-Some have also mentioned that there is an Initial funding of 95k, which converts the account to 0 MAB acc when infact originally the account was supposed to be a 10k MAB account. So would like some clarification on this.
If I do proceed with the 95k funding, can I withdraw the entire amount in a couple of days and will the account remain 0 MAB for LifeTime or would I have to maintain some balance in it? Also which DC do you get here and does it have a JF and AF? Not able to find proper documentations.
3. Axis
After going through this thread, I have decided to put Axis on hold. Since my aim for this account was Airtel Axis CC, I will try applying for the CC directly
Once again 2 straightforward accounts here
- Easy Access Digital Savings - 16k initial funding, 12k MAB, Free VDC but Physical DC is 500+gst JF & AF and both VDC and PhyDC seem to be not that great.
- Liberty Savings - 25k initial funding, 25k MAB, PhyDC is 200+gst JF and 300+gst AF which seems fine. Seems to have all benifits of DC from Easy Access acc. ( As per advice by @Mr. Bean but will put this on hold since another thread I just went through mentions that Axis is infamous for levying unncessary charges on the account)
5. Kotak (Opened 811 SuperSavings)
811 ZeroBalance Digital Savings - 0 MAB, free VDC, Physical Classic DC on request @ 299/yr811 Edge Savings - 10k MAB, no VDC, Physical Platinum DC @ 235/yr- 811 SuperSavings acc - 0 MAB, 5000 deposit every month, 300/yr subscription fee ( As per advice by @Fini7777 )
I dont see much of a difference between the two, the ZeroBalance Digital SB should suffice with just VDC.
Also would it make sense to go for 811 Super Savings, assuming I dont get put on a waitlist? It does not have any MAB requirement either but subscription fee of 300/yr is applicable + every month you have to do a hard deposit of 5000 in a single txn. Can this be immediately withdrawn?
Thank you for reading till the end!
I will keep updating the post as I receive clarification and suggestions.
Your help is greatly appreciated!
Last edited: