• Hey there! Welcome to TFC! View fewer ads on the website just by signing up on TF Community.

Using HDFC Bank credit cards reduces one's credit score

evanferrao

TF Buzz
HDFC doesn't report credit limit to credit bureaus. They say that according to RBI, it's not mandatory to report credit limit (which may be true). But credit utilization is an important factor in calculation of credit score. Thus, most credit bureaus just use the highest used amount as the credit limit. My card currently has a limit of INR 550000, the highest ever used was 139678, the latter of which is considered to be the credit limit by CIBIL and Experian.

Say, I spend 125000 next month. According to HDFC, my utilization would be 22.727% which is well under the 30% recommended limit. However, according to CIBIL and Experian, the utilization would be 90%, which is an immediate red flag, and would surely result in a decrease in credit score. Unlike Credit Enquires and number of accounts, which are low impact parameters, credit utilization and payments are high impact parameters. So, the drop in score should be pretty significant.

There seems to be no solution for now. Big Brain (or rather small) move by HDFC Bank. Penalizing you for using their card and keeping utilization under 30%. The only way one can get around is to get the card, spend its max limit, which will update the credit limit in CIBIL and Experian. This too, however, would temporarily decrease the credit score as the card is maxed out. The “workaround” is as dumb as the employee in charge decided it would be funny if HDFC didn't report credit limit to credit bureaus.

TLDR; HDFC doesn't care about your credit score. Limit their card usage only for availing offers on Amazon/Flipkart etc. For other purchases, it's not worth using a card that actively hurts your score for spending cautiously.
TLDR2; Use HDFC cards only if you have other cards, since the limit of the other cards will bring down ones overall utilization ratio.

Images attached below for reference.
(spending even 20k leaves me with a utilization of 15%)
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20230311-094724_Brave.png
    Screenshot_20230311-094724_Brave.png
    43.4 KB · Views: 163
  • Screenshot_20230311-095703_OneScore.png
    Screenshot_20230311-095703_OneScore.png
    36.2 KB · Views: 165
  • Screenshot_20230311-095714_OneScore.png
    Screenshot_20230311-095714_OneScore.png
    36.4 KB · Views: 154
  • Screenshot_20230311-095732_OneScore.png
    Screenshot_20230311-095732_OneScore.png
    47.7 KB · Views: 163
Last edited:
the app that you use is displaying data incorrectly as max limit. as far as i know, credit beaureaus doesnt consider the limit for calculation for score for at least hdfc. i can say this because my spends on my hdfc cards are more or less the same each month, which by your logic should be a approx 90% utilization. but my credit scorce only increased, not dropped.
 
Thats because you might have other cards with high limit and low utilisation. If you had only hdfc card with same usage every month then your score will decrease every month
Very true. For end calculations it's all cards vs. Limit utilised from what I've seen.
Some apps like Airtel & gPay show the utilisation % and the relating impacts
 
HDFC doesn't report credit limit to credit bureaus. They say that according to RBI, it's not mandatory to report credit limit (which may be true). But credit utilization is an important factor in calculation of credit score. Thus, most credit bureaus just use the highest used amount as the credit limit. My card currently has a limit of INR 550000, the highest ever used was 139678, the latter of which is considered to be the credit limit by CIBIL and Experian.

Say, I spend 125000 next month. According to HDFC, my utilization would be 22.727% which is well under the 30% recommended limit. However, according to CIBIL and Experian, the utilization would be 90%, which is an immediate red flag, and would surely result in a decrease in credit score. Unlike Credit Enquires and number of accounts, which are low impact parameters, credit utilization and payments are high impact parameters. So, the drop in score should be pretty significant.

There seems to be no solution for now. Big Brain (or rather small) move by HDFC Bank. Penalizing you for using their card and keeping utilization under 30%. The only way one can get around is to get the card, spend its max limit, which will update the credit limit in CIBIL and Experian. This too, however, would temporarily decrease the credit score as the card is maxed out. The “workaround” is as dumb as the employee in charge decided it would be funny if HDFC didn't report credit limit to credit bureaus.

TLDR; HDFC doesn't care about your credit score. Limit their card usage only for availing offers on Amazon/Flipkart etc. For other purchases, it's not worth using a card that actively hurts your score for spending cautiously.
TLDR2; Use HDFC cards only if you have other cards, since the limit of the other cards will bring down ones overall utilization ratio.

Images attached below for reference.
(spending even 20k leaves me with a utilization of 15%)
But in my case I think HDFC reports credit card limit to credit bureaus...look attached pictures
My CC limit is 1.5Lakh which is mentioned in CIBIL report.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20230815_205735.jpg
    IMG_20230815_205735.jpg
    119.7 KB · Views: 10
  • IMG_20230815_205757.jpg
    IMG_20230815_205757.jpg
    40.5 KB · Views: 10
Agree, even in my case they are reporting exact CC limit now 😄🤣 😃 😆
View attachment 26734
Yes ... as said earlier, it had kicked in for more than 2 months ago..
More details here:

 
Yes ... as said earlier, it had kicked in for more than 2 months ago..
More details here:

You tagged the wrong person. 🤭
 
  • Hehe
Reactions: SSV
Back
Top