CIBIL dropped from 780 to 730sh

[VasukiVasuki is verified member.]

I already have 12. Cancelled one yesterday.
Yes, trying to figure out how it should be done in order to minimise the damage.

If u stomach is full & you aren't looking big next 3-5 month .u can close .

All depends on you

 

[citboins234]

Buy Cibil 6 month subscription & find out yourself.
Usually it should make a big jump upto 750 ish in 2-3 month

That's why I'm tolerating this HDFC card which is oldest😀

Exactly. I had regalia forst, bank refused to upgrade. So when 3rd party approached in our office, i took regalia. But as you can't have more than one hdfc cc (except co branded), had to close older.

 

[deep@vie]

Exactly. I had regalia forst, bank refused to upgrade. So when 3rd party approached in our office, i took regalia. But as you can't have more than one hdfc cc (except co branded), had to close older.

I've regalia but these idiots not enhancing limit.

 

[deep@vie]

If u stomach is full & you aren't looking big next 3-5 month .u can close .

All depends on you

I've very good metabolism hence I feel hungry all the time So, no for now. 🤣

 

[citboins234]

My guess is because of this

But that card was closed in 2022. Almost 1.5 years ago. Shouldn't cibil be normalised by now?

 

[citboins234]

I've regalia but these idiots not enhancing limit.

Yup. They are not very keen on increasing. When i requested RM about limit increase, they asked 3 months salary slips and provided link to fill form, print and mail it to Chennai office via them. All for mere 2k limit increase.

 

[citboins234]

I

Close it no problem, even if there is any effect, it’s only going to be short lived..

I checked in gpay cibil predictor, it actually shows that cibil will increase by 5 points, if i close immediately.

 

[VasukiVasuki is verified member.]

But that card was closed in 2022. Almost 1.5 years ago. Shouldn't cibil be normalised by now?

See your cibil report .
If u can buy cibil premium

 

[AkashnAkashn is verified member.]

But that card was closed in 2022. Almost 1.5 years ago. Shouldn't cibil be normalised by now?

Yeah. You should start monitoring cibil score from now on. Every week. Use Gpay, Onescore, airtel app, axis cibil. These are spam free app/websites.

 

[Deleted member 19066]

If u stomach is full & you aren't looking big next 3-5 month .u can close .

All depends on you

I Closed 8 Credit CARDS. LAST YEAR BUT STILL MY SCORE IS NEVER DROPPED

 

[VasukiVasuki is verified member.]

I Closed 8 Credit CARDS. LAST YEAR BUT STILL MY SCORE IS NEVER DROPPED

Closing oldest has much value .
If other card is much newer compared to oldest .

 

[imdjay]

Closing oldest has much value .
If other card is much newer compared to oldest .

According to the CIBIL simulator, If I close my oldest card, my score will increase by 2. Only god knows their algorithm. 🤣

 

[VasukiVasuki is verified member.]

According to the CIBIL simulator, If I close my oldest card, my score will increase by 2. Only god knows their algorithm. 🤣

Maybe old isn't too old

 

[SSV]

Maybe old isn't too old

Or the second oldest is also too old!! 😉

 

[imdjay]

Maybe old isn't too old

It's around 6 years old.

Or the second oldest is also too old!! 😉

The second oldest is 5 years old.

 

[VasukiVasuki is verified member.]

It's around 6 years old.

The second oldest is 5 years old.

You answered yourself 🙂

 

[imdjay]

You answered yourself 🙂

but no one has ever said closing the oldest will increase the CIBIL. everyone thinks it might decrease or not affect the CIBIL at all.

 

[SSV]

It's around 6 years old.

The second oldest is 5 years old.

Basically 5 years is a kind-of threshold for more stable score

 

[VasukiVasuki is verified member.]

but no one has ever said closing the oldest will increase the CIBIL. everyone thinks it might decrease or not affect the CIBIL at all.

Depends on overall profile.
Closing my oldest account ( loan - bnpl Flipkart) increased my score 😎

 

[SSV]

but no one has ever said closing the oldest will increase the CIBIL. everyone thinks it might decrease or not affect the CIBIL at all.

That is also correct. It also depends on other factors..
Cibil is the most consistent among the 4 and their simulator worked 💯 for me in the last 3 years